How we rank car rental companies in Madeira
Last updated
The ranked list is a score out of 100. Each criterion below is scored from facts we have checked on the company's own website, by the written rule shown, and the scores are added. Nobody edits a position by hand. This page lists every criterion, its weight and its rule, so you can work out any company's score yourself from the facts on its page.
The criteria and their weights
| Criterion | Weight | How it is scored |
|---|---|---|
| Deposit | 25 | A genuine no-deposit option, where the company states that no deposit is held, scores the full 25. Otherwise the deposit amount scores up to 20: 20 points at €0, falling in a straight line to 0 at €2,000 or more. A range such as €800-€2,000 is scored at its midpoint. Another 5 points are added when the company accepts a debit card or does not require a credit card for the deposit. "Sometimes" earns nothing. |
| Excess on the basic cover | 20 | Lower is better: 20 points at €0, falling in a straight line to 0 at €2,000 or more. A range is scored at its midpoint. |
| Price of full cover per day | 15 | Full cover included in the rental price scores the full 15. Otherwise the daily price of full cover scores 15 at €0, falling in a straight line to 0 at €30 a day or more. A range is scored at its midpoint. |
| Fuel policy | 10 | Full to full scores 10. Pre-purchase scores 0. Any other stated policy (same to same, full to empty) scores 5. |
| Pickup | 10 | A desk in the terminal, meet and greet, or delivery to you scores 10. A shuttle to an off-site depot, or a depot-only pickup, scores 5. |
| Terms published | 10 | Five items count: deposit, excess, price of full cover, fuel policy and pickup. Each one that is published on the company's own site or terms page scores 2. An item we could not read on the company's own pages scores 0 for that item. |
| Residents' picks | 10 | One point for each pick from a named Madeira resident, up to 10. |
| Commercial relationship | 0 | We earn a commission from DiscoverCars on bookings made through links on this site. It carries zero weight: it is not an input to the score. |
| Total | 100 |
No residents' picks have been added yet, so every company scores 0 on that criterion today.
A missing fact scores zero
If we have not checked a fact, the company scores 0 for that criterion. We do not fill the gap with an average or a guess. The ranking therefore rewards companies that publish their terms clearly on their own sites, and a company can rise as we check more of its facts.
Who gets a position
A company is ranked only when we have checked at least 5 facts about it that tell companies apart. Facts that are true of almost every company do not count toward the 5: basic cover (CDW) included, airport pickup, a deposit is required, full cover (Super CDW) offered, automatic cars available, a young-driver surcharge. Without that rule, every company we have not read would sit at the bottom of the table for no reason except that nobody had checked it.
Today 27 of 61 companies are ranked. The others are listed alphabetically under "Not yet checked", with no figures and no position.
These companies have not been checked against their own published terms yet. Some, including several international brands, publish their deposit and excess only in the booking process or at the counter, so we cannot show those figures.
How ties work
Companies are ordered by total score. When two companies have the same score, the one with more checked facts goes first. If they are still level, they share one position (for example 1, 1, 3), the page says they are tied, and tied companies are shown in alphabetical order.
What counts as a source
A fact is shown only with the address of the page it was read on, the kind of page and the date we read it. The pages that count are the company's own website, its terms and conditions, its rental conditions and its FAQ, on the company's own domain. Figures that appear only inside a booking flow do not count, and neither do rating sites, map listings or the listing of the company on a booking site.
Star ratings and review counts from any site are not used and are not shown. This list holds no ratings of its own.
How facts are read
An AI assistant reads each company's own terms pages and extracts the values; every value is checked by code against a quoted passage from the page, and a person reviews the list before it is published.
How we are paid
We earn a commission from DiscoverCars when you book some of these companies through our links. Every link that goes through DiscoverCars says so next to the link. The commission carries zero weight in the score, so it never changes the order.
Corrections
If a fact on this site is wrong, tell us through the contact page or on WhatsApp and include the page on the company's own website that shows the right figure. We check it against that page. If the fact is wrong, we correct it and add a line to the corrections log. A company can also ask for a short reply to be shown beside its listing. We do not remove or change a fact because a company would like a different figure.
